The Myth of the Digital Workplace Hub
“I just want one place to go for everything” is a common refrain I hear from employees when discussing their digital workplace. You’ll also frequently hear software vendors and consultants talk about intranets (and more recently Microsoft Teams) as being a ‘digital workplace hub,’ a ‘single pane of glass’ or an ‘enterprise front door.’ On the surface it sounds appealing because it sounds simple, but I reckon that if you ever achieved it, you wouldn’t want it. It’s a bit like how a one-stop-shop sounds like a convenience store but turns out to be a mega-mart.
What a Digital Workplace Hub Looks Like
Usually when people pitch the idea of a single entry-point, they visualize something like this:
The implication is that everything routes through one place, usually an intranet. But in reality, it would be very limiting. For example, if I’m on Yammer and want to share a photo from Dropbox, I’d like Yammer to access Dropbox directly, and not have to fire up a hub to make that happen. So in practice things are already much messier, but also more networked (we might call it an internal net, or InterNet for short … remember folks, you heard it here first).
Related Article: Going Digital Doesn't Mean You Have a Digital Workplace
Nobody Starts Their Workday From the Same Entry Point
A second problem with the hub concept is that people in different roles will want different starting points. An engineer using a CAD system every day isn’t going to first fire up the intranet to click on the link in the Tools menu (even if it is seductively called Quick Links). A sales representative will have Salesforce open first thing, they don’t need another system to get there.
Moreover, each user type probably doesn’t want to see those other tools. Their digital workplace world looks more like this:
Software vendors might argue that their system does that with personalization. But remember, people are bypassing that personalization layer and doing it for themselves on their device desktop or home screen.
Related Article: One Dashboard Will Never Be Enough in the Digital Workplace
Hubs Are Fragile
I’m assuming that a hub is doing more than just linking out, so that users interact via the hub rather than going into another app. There’s definitely an economy in having a layer that brokers connections so that you only need an API between different systems. However, there are also multiple downsides to a hub and spoke approach:
- It’s a single point of failure: if the hub breaks you can’t do anything.
- It will be a poor UX as the hub interface isn’t optimized for each use case.
- Although there are many systems that have lots of connectors (e.g. Teams, Slack, Zapier) no single solution covers all bases.
If there’s one thing the internet has taught us, it’s that a centralized approach is less desirable than a distributed one.
Related Article: One Collaboration Tool to Rule Them All? Think Again
Is Microsoft Teams a Digital Workplace Hub?
Microsoft Teams frequently comes up in this context, with some pitching Teams as the new digital workplace hub. After all, it has several hundred connectors and the ability to surface content from other applications on tabs.
Making the Complex Possible: How to Accelerate Your Digital Transformation
Hear how leading companies are reimagining their digital transformation projects and identifying new opportunities for growth.Watch NowON DEMAND
The Race for Digital Transformation: Employee-Centric IT Against the Odds (with Paddy Power Betfair)
In this webinar, we’ll explore real-world use cases that illustrate the transformational benefits of employee-centric IT.Watch Now
How to Use Space Reservation Tools to Return to the Office Safely
Explore the innovative tools that help make the transition back to hybrid and in-office work seamless.Watch NowON DEMAND
Liberty Mutual: Building a Center of Excellence for Employee Experience
Explore how to implement a cross-departmental center for employee experience and make the biggest impact.Watch Now
And there’s certainly value in this as a way to make some tasks slicker. A team working on customer problems may pull in a tab showing help desk tickets, for example. But to me this is creating a specific dashboard and not a universal hub.
As soon as you try to add in all the infrequently used systems, Teams becomes a mess because it doesn’t readily support the kind of signposting you need when in unfamiliar territory. Sure, you can embed an intranet home page into Teams, but that’s superficial — it’s no more integrated than saying your browser is a hub because everything you do is in the cloud.
The second limitation of Teams as the universal entry point is that it only works if everyone's jobs require Teams to be routinely open. For many roles, Teams will be an infrequent tool. Frontline workers, specialists and those in operational roles are much more likely to live in a system designed specifically for their workflow, and only drop into Teams when needed.
Related Article: New Together Mode Shows Microsoft Teams Is in It to Win It
The Problem Hubs Try to Solve
Let’s backtrack and consider the problem(s) a hub is meant to solve. Digital workplaces have multiple, very real pain-points including:
- Too many places to monitor for updates, so employees lose track of what's happening.
- Fragmented content, making it hard to get information to make a decision.
- Too many interfaces to learn.
- Too many options for what to use when.
The front door metaphor works when you are new and need signposting, or when you are doing something infrequent, such as changing a pension plan. In this scenario you want to know where to start to begin looking. It’s like when you go to a shopping mall the first time and you use the main entrance to look at the map. After that, if you know you want the pharmacy, you go straight in via the side door that’s much closer.
A Better Vision Than a Hub
I’d like to propose a more adaptable way to address the problems hubs try to solve:
- Flexible entry points. We should let people choose the entry point that suits their work. This is where they will be focussed and is the thing they will fire up first, like the icons you put on the first screen of your phone. It happens at the operating system level.
- Aggregated notifications. We should then support the challenge of keeping track of updates by aggregating notifications. It is knowing what to attend to, rather than having everything in one place that is the issue. At the moment too many notifications still appear as emails with links. We can do better by making the notification an actionable card, for example to approve an expense or confirm a discount. If the response is more involved then it is OK to take someone into an interface that has been optimized for that task.
- Proper search. Rather than trying to bring everything into one place to make it easier to find things, we need to get much better at indexing multiple sources and presenting unified search results.
- Signposting for infrequent tools and information. Notifications and search don’t work when someone needs to use a service for the first time and doesn’t know the name or what the options are. In this scenario, an intranet or other presentation-rich tool works well.
If all that aggregation still sounds like a hub, then let me emphasize a final point: having put all these connections in place, we should then surface them wherever makes sense to the individual. That may vary across work styles in the same organization. For people who work all the time in Teams, the notifications may appear there alongside chat and task notifications. For frontline workers, your universal search may exist in a dedicated employee app, and for others it may be an overlay that sometimes they access in the browser, and sometimes as an app.
Related Article: What Microservices Bring to the Digital Workplace
About the Author
Sam Marshall is the owner of ClearBox Consulting and has specialized in intranets and the digital workplace for over 18 years, working with companies such as AstraZeneca, Diageo, Sony, GSK and AkzoNobel.
He is the lead author of the annual SharePoint Intranets in-a-box review.
Atlassian Adds New Features, Workplace by Facebook Hits Customer Milestone & More News
Facebook Workplace Surpasses 7M Paid Subscribers, Introduces New App Integrations
Mendix Updates Low-Code Platform, Thoma Bravo Buys Proofpoint for $12.3B and More News