Feature
Talent acquisition and HR are like that mismatched couple everyone wonders about. Talent acquisition is the flashy one — the recruiter swaggering into a room with a knack for salesmanship, closing deals and hitting quotas. HR is the dependable type, focused on nurturing, developing and retaining people once they're in the door.
These so-called partners have operated more like acquaintances for years now. Suggest that the two work more closely together, as I've done at various HR and recruiting events and in columns like this, and you are met with dismissal or rejection.
But the distance between them is shrinking as companies start to break down the walls between talent acquisition and talent management to build more unified, effective talent strategies.
Why now? Because AI and automation are rewriting the rules of recruiting. Closer integration is dissolving silos — whether recruiters like it or not. The question is no longer whether talent acquisition can remain siloed from HR, but whether they have the political capital to keep that arm’s length relationship alive.
Why Recruiters Built Their Own Island
Talent acquisition has always sat at the periphery of the HR umbrella. In organizations like retail or hospitality, its transactional, high-speed nature — focused on sourcing, screening and hiring — has little in common with HR’s broader focus on retention, employee development and long-term strategy. Even in organizations where talent acquisition is slower and more strategic, it can still feel like a world removed from the recruiters who must deal with the external realities of the talent market.
Recruiters often see HR as too bureaucratic and focused on internal processes that have nothing to do with bringing fresh talent into the company. They’re not necessarily wrong. The skills required for talent acquisition and talent management are wildly different.
The divide was functional, maybe even necessary, for a while. Talent acquisition could operate independently, and HR was happy to leave the fast-paced hiring work to the recruiters.
But there’s always been a problem: when your department’s success is measured by how quickly you fill vacancies, the focus rarely extends beyond the hiring moment. Time to hire is a terrible metric but it’s still far too common. Once a candidate signs on the dotted line, a recruiter’s job is done. But in a world where talent scarcity is a major concern, that just doesn’t cut it anymore.
Automation and AI Are Breaking Down Recruiting Barriers
AI and automation have thrown a wrench into the old ways of doing things. You don't have to tell recruiting leaders that.
Companies are now using AI to streamline sourcing, screening, interview scheduling and even candidate engagement. Tools like AI-driven applicant tracking systems now parse resumes, match skills and rank candidates faster than human recruiters ever could — though that can come with challenges. Chatbots handle scheduling and basic Q&A, making the candidate experience feel seamless.
More importantly, automation frees recruiters from tedious administrative tasks, letting them focus on strategic work. But that strategic work is increasingly about building better talent pipelines, predicting workforce needs and thinking beyond just filling immediate roles. The data recruiters gather about candidates — skills, experience, ambitions — has enormous value for talent management.
The most ironic part is that automation is making talent acquisition more like talent management, whether recruiters want it or not. When AI identifies a great candidate who doesn’t fit the current opening but could be valuable down the line, that’s not information that can just sit in talent acquisition. It’s an important workforce planning insight, too.
The Case for Integrating Talent Acquisition and Talent Management
The truth is, integrating talent acquisition and talent management offers significant advantages:
- Improved Strategic Alignment — Companies can hire for potential, not just immediate fit, ensuring new hires are prepared to grow within the company.
- Enhanced Experience — From recruitment to onboarding and beyond, a smoother, more cohesive experience for candidates and employees alike.
- Data-Driven Insights — Insights gathered from recruiting processes can be applied to talent development and retention.
- Collaboration Within HR — Breaking down silos creates a unified, agile talent strategy.
Lowe’s now uses a single, integrated model to streamline communication and build talent mobility across HR. Ray Malouf, vice president of talent at Lowe’s, told HR Executive, “We can represent a single voice to the business now.”
Malouf said success in this marriage also means being curious. Doing research on the business, being open to alternative approaches, growing your skill set, and helping to navigate the change successfully all matter in making the strategy and execution work.
Why This Integration Is Inevitable — And Good
Here’s the truth: All aspects of talent are being disrupted, not just recruiting.
Conference
Oct
20
Gartner IT Symposium/Xpo Orlando 2025
Register
Conference
Oct
27
Gartner HR Symposium/Xpo Orlando 2025
Register
But recruiters are at the tip of the spear. They’re the ones dealing with the latest AI tools, the ones seeing how the data they collect could be used far beyond hiring. The ones regularly exposed to the rapidly changing expectations of the talent marketplace.
Ultimately, companies that recognize talent acquisition and talent management as two parts of a single, unified strategy will be the ones that win. Because in a rapidly changing talent landscape, survival isn’t about protecting old ways of doing things. It’s about tearing them down and building something stronger in their place.
Editor's Note: Read more about the changing world of HR and recruiting:
- How I Decided to Launch an AI Chatbot in Our Recruiting Process — Franciscan Health's Ellen Page shares how her team decided to introduce an AI chatbot into its recruiting process and the outsized impact it has had.
- We've Only Seen the Start of Regulations Around AI in Recruiting — New York City may have been the first to introduce legislation regulating the use of automated employee decision tools, but it definitely won't be the last.
- 2025 Predictions for AI in Work Tech — HR leaders need to understand how AI can unlock new possibilities. Here we explore some of the most promising applications.
